The Resume

(March 5, 1980- )
Born in Logan, Utah
Birth name is Shay Carl Butler
YouTube and Social Media Personality
Attained over six million collectives subscribers
Main channels are Shaycarl (created 2006) and SHAYTARDS (created 2008)
Films vlogs with his wife, Colette ('Katilette'), and their five children
Catchphrase is 'I'm Vlogging Here!'

Why he might be annoying:

He admitted to alcohol abuse on Twitter.
His second channel name is a one-off of the term 'retard.'
He 'retired' from Vlogging only to return and restart his YouTube channel a year later.
He got his wife and kids involved in his VLogs (and the subsequent drama), opening the door for more exploitative and tasteless imitators, like the DaddyOFive Channel.
He was caught exchanging sexual messages with an adult webcam model behind his wife's back, and then filmed an insincere apology video begging for his subscribers' forgiveness (2017).

Why he might not be annoying:

His first video to go viral was of him prancing around in his wife's unitard.
He was a Latter Day Saints missionary in the Caribbean after graduating high school.
Forbes called him one of the 'most successful video entrepreneurs on YouTube.'
He lost over 100 pounds and documented his weight loss on his channel.
He won Best YouTube Channel Personality at Mashable's 3rd annual Open Web Awards (2009).
His channel was ranked #31 on New Media Rockstars Top 100 Channels.
He took time off from YouTube to get counseling and help repair his marriage.
Matt Damon and Charles Barkley have guested on his channels.

Credit: BoyWiththeGreenHair

Featured in the following Annoying Collections:

• BoyWiththeGreenHair’s Profiles [Series 13]
• Breeders [Have 5 or More Kids] (Ranked: 5)
• Celebrity Fashion Lines
• College Drop Outs
• Do As I Say Not As I Do [Conservative Hypocrites]
• Epic Rap Battles of History [Complete] (Ranked: 6)
• Epic Rap Battles of History [Season 6] (Ranked: 12)
• I am an Angelino [Residents of Los Angeles]
• I am on Cameo
• I Attended Alcohol Anonymous
• I Became a Dad in 2005
• I Became a Dad in 2007
• I Became a Dad in 2010
• I Became a Dad in 2013
• I Married in 2003
• I Portrayed Henry VIII
• I Ran a Marathon
• I Retired, Just Kidding
• I'm Sorry [Public Apologies]
• Known By a Middle Name
• Look at Me, I'm Relaxing
• Look at Me, I'm Wearing a Baseball Cap
• Profiles 45501-45750 (Ranked: 45545)
• Streamy Icon Awards [2014]
• Target Models/Advertisers
• The Kids From The Fine Bros' 'Kids React' Reacted To My Video
• YouTube Celebrities

Year In Review:

For 2024, as of last weekly ranking, Out of 2 Votes: 100% Annoying
In 2023, Out of 4 Votes: 100% Annoying
In 2022, Out of 130 Votes: 54.62% Annoying
In 2021, Out of 5 Votes: 80.0% Annoying
In 2020, Out of 11 Votes: 81.82% Annoying
In 2019, Out of 18 Votes: 50.0% Annoying